Planning a long road trip can be exciting. However, choosing the right vehicle for the journey is just as important as packing your bags. When you go on a road trip or drive a long way to visit family, comfort is important. Fuel efficiency matters too. Safety is essential as well.
Two of the most common options for long drives are SUVs and sedans. But which one offers the better experience?
In this comprehensive guide, we will explore several key factors. These include comfort, fuel efficiency, safety, cargo space, handling, and cost. Our goal is to assist you in selecting the best option for your upcoming long trip. In this comprehensive guide, we will explore several key factors. These include comfort, fuel efficiency, safety, cargo space, handling, and cost. Our goal is to assist you in selecting the best option for your upcoming long trip.
Table of Contents
1. Comfort on Long Drives: SUV vs Sedan
Comfort is arguably the most important factor when you’re on the road for hours. How does each vehicle compare?
Sedan Comfort
Sedans are known for their smooth rides. Because of their lower center of gravity and sedan-specific suspension systems, they absorb bumps better on paved roads.
- Seat Design: Many modern sedans offer cushioned, supportive seating with good lumbar support, especially in mid- to high-end models.
- Noise Insulation: Sedans tend to have better cabin insulation due to their compact design, which helps reduce road noise.
- Ride Quality: Sedans usually offer more stable handling on highways, reducing motion fatigue over long distances.
SUV Comfort
SUVs provide a different kind of comfort, particularly for those who like space and visibility.
- Spacious Interiors: Most SUVs offer more legroom and headroom, especially in the second row, which is great for families or taller passengers.
- Seating Flexibility: Many SUVs come with adjustable rear seats, reclining functions, and even third-row seating for large groups.
- High Driving Position: The elevated driver’s seat provides a commanding view of the road, which can feel safer and less tiring for some drivers.
Verdict: If you mainly drive on highways and travel alone or with one companion, a sedan could offer more comfort. But for group trips or anyone who values space, the SUV wins.
2. Fuel Efficiency and Mileage
Fuel cost adds up quickly on long trips, so choosing a fuel-efficient car is essential.
Sedan Fuel Economy
Sedans generally win in this category.
- Efficiency: Compact and mid-sized sedans regularly offer 30–40 MPG on highways.
- Hybrid Options: Sedans like the Toyota Camry Hybrid or Honda Accord Hybrid can exceed 45 MPG, reducing fuel stops significantly.
- Lower Drag Coefficient: Their aerodynamic design helps reduce resistance and improves efficiency.
SUV Fuel Economy
SUVs consume more fuel—though newer models are improving.
- Traditional SUVs: Full-sized or off-road SUVs may only offer 15–25 MPG.
- Crossover SUVs: Crossovers and compact SUVs perform better, often reaching 25–30 MPG.
- Hybrid SUVs: Models like the Toyota RAV4 Hybrid can deliver MPG figures close to sedans.
Verdict: Sedans have the edge if fuel efficiency is a top priority, but hybrid SUVs are closing the gap fast.
3. Storage and Cargo Capacity
When you’re traveling long distances, you’ll likely carry luggage, snacks, gear, and more.
Sedan Cargo Space
- Limited Trunk Room: Most sedans have trunk space ranging from 12 to 16 cubic feet. That’s enough for 2–3 medium suitcases.
- No Vertical Space: The fixed trunk roof limits the ability to carry taller or oddly shaped items.
- Fold-Down Seats: Many sedans offer fold-down rear seats, which helps, but not substantially.
SUV Cargo Space
- Huge Storage Area: SUVs usually offer between 30 and 70+ cubic feet of cargo space when rear seats are folded.
- Flexible Storage: The upright design allows stacking and larger item storage.
- Roof Rails: Many SUVs come with roof rails, making it easier to mount cargo boxes or bike racks.
Verdict: SUV takes the lead. If you’re carrying lots of luggage, sports gear, or traveling with kids, SUVs provide far more flexibility and room.
4. Road Handling and Driving Experience
How does it feel behind the wheel over a 6- or 10-hour drive?
Sedan Road Handling
- Smoother Ride: Sedans hug the road better thanks to their lower stance.
- Precise Steering: Better cornering and responsiveness make them more enjoyable for driving enthusiasts.
- Lower Wind Resistance: Less swaying on windy days, contributing to a calmer experience.
SUV Road Handling
- Heavier Ride: The higher center of gravity and weight can lead to body roll in sharp turns.
- More Capable on Mixed Terrain: SUVs handle gravel roads, steep inclines, and snow better than sedans.
- All-Wheel Drive (AWD): Many SUVs come with AWD or 4WD options, ideal for unpredictable routes.
Verdict: Sedans offer a more refined road feel, but SUVs excel in mixed terrains and offer better all-weather traction.
5. Safety Features and Crash Ratings
Long drives mean more exposure to risk—so safety is critical.
Sedan Safety
- High Crash Ratings: Many sedans score top marks in crash tests due to their compact and controlled design.
- Standard Features: Features like ABS, traction control, adaptive cruise control, and lane-keeping assist are now common.
- Crash Avoidance: Because they’re lower to the ground, sedans may be easier to maneuver in sudden braking situations.
SUV Safety
- High Driving Position: Provides better visibility, which can help avoid potential hazards.
- Size Advantage: Larger size may offer more protection in a crash, especially in front-end collisions.
- More Weight: While this helps in stability, it also means longer stopping distances.
Verdict: Both vehicle types have great safety options, but SUVs offer more protection due to size—while sedans may be easier to control in emergencies.
6. Cost Considerations (Initial and Long-Term)
Budget matters. So which type of vehicle is lighter on your wallet?
Sedan Costs
- Lower Initial Cost: Sedans are generally $5,000–$10,000 cheaper than similar SUVs.
- Better Fuel Economy: Saves money on gas over the lifetime of the vehicle.
- Cheaper Maintenance: Fewer parts, smaller tires, and simpler suspension systems mean lower repair bills.
SUV Costs
- Higher Purchase Price: Expect to pay more for the same brand/model class.
- Fuel and Insurance: SUVs usually cost more to fuel and insure.
- Resale Value: SUVs often hold their value better because of high demand, especially for family-friendly models.
Verdict: Sedans win in affordability, but SUVs can be a better long-term investment if you plan to sell or trade in later.
7. Who Should Choose an SUV?
SUVs shine when space, flexibility, and terrain variety matter.
You should consider an SUV for long drives if:
- You travel with family, pets, or large groups.
- You need to carry lots of luggage or outdoor equipment.
- You drive through mixed or off-road conditions.
- You prioritize a higher driving position and all-weather capability.
Popular SUV picks for long trips:
- Toyota Highlander
- Honda CR-V
- Subaru Outback
- Ford Explorer
- Mazda CX-5
8. Who Should Choose a Sedan?
Sedans are best for those who value efficiency and refined driving.
Choose a sedan if:
- You mostly drive on highways and paved roads.
- You travel solo or with one passenger.
- You want better fuel economy and lower costs.
- You prefer a quieter, smoother ride.
Top sedans for long road trips:
- Honda Accord
- Toyota Camry
- Hyundai Sonata
- Tesla Model 3 (EV efficiency)
- Mazda6
9. The Hybrid Solution: Best of Both Worlds?
If you can’t decide between the two, hybrid and crossover vehicles might be the sweet spot.
- Crossovers (like the Toyota RAV4 or Subaru Crosstrek) combine sedan comfort with SUV practicality.
- Hybrid SUVs and Sedans offer fuel efficiency with modern features.
- Plug-in Hybrids and EVs: Perfect for those looking to reduce environmental impact while still enjoying road trip comforts.
Final Verdict: SUV vs Sedan for Long Drives
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It depends on your needs, lifestyle, and travel preferences.
If you travel light, value fuel efficiency, and prefer smooth highway cruises—go with a sedan. But if you need more room, love scenic detours, or plan to travel with a group, an SUV might be your road-trip soulmate. Think about your usual road trip needs, and you’ll make the right call.
Safe travels, and enjoy the journey—no matter which vehicle you choose!
Also Read:
Oliver is a professional blogger and a seasoned business and finance writer. With a passion for simplifying complex financial topics, he provides valuable insights to a diverse online audience. With four years of experience, Oliver has polished his skills as a finance blogger.
